z2-Environment

h1. How to use the Spring framework in Z2

There is actually nothing really particular about using Spring in Z2. But when knowing how Z2 modularity works, there is much to gain by spending a few minutes reading this Howto. We assume however that you are familiar with the Spring framework as such.

It may be best to inspect the the basic [[Sample-spring-basic]] sample in parallel to reading this page, as that makes use of most of what you will find here and is still really simple. Plus, running the sample requires no more than Eclipse and five minutes of your time.

Other samples highlight specific integrations that may look interesting to you:

* [[Sample-spring-hibernate]] shows how to use Spring with Hibernate and Z2's built-in basic transaction management,

* [[Sample-jta-spring]] shows how to use Spring with Hibernate and the Atomikos transaction manager,

* [[Sample-springds-hibernate]] shows how to use Spring with Hibernate and Spring's basic basic transaction management

by here you should have noted that transaction handling is obviously a noteworthy cross-cutting concern.

* [[Sample-vaadin-spring-hibernate]] shows a blueprint for a rich-internet-application built on Vaadin, Spring, and Hibernate

Please also check the add-on page [[Spring add-on]]. The Spring add-on should be considered an example on how to make use of Spring with Z2. It adds extremely useful support functionality for a seamless aspectj-driven annotation based application configuration which, turning the combination of Z2 and Spring into a first-class, flexible, extensible, productive, and scalable application server environment.

h2. Pre-requisites

In order to have the Spring libraries available you need to add the add-on [[Spring add-on]] via the repository "z2-addons.spring":http://redmine.z2-environment.net/projects/z2-addons/repository/z2-addons-spring to your environment (the samples do so in their _environment_).  To use the master branch version, add a *springRepository.properties* component descriptor to your *environment* module saying

<pre><code class="python">

com.zfabrik.systemStates.participation=com.zfabrik.boot.main/sysrepo_up

# git stored component repository

com.zfabrik.component.type=com.zfabrik.gitcr

# true <=> optional repository. If gitcr.uri is invalid, then this gitcr will be ignore silently  

gitcr.optional=true

# this can also point to a remote repository like 

# ssh://myserver/some/git/repo

gitcr.uri=http://git.z2-environment.net/z2-addons.spring

# the git branch to use (e.g. 'master')

gitcr.branch=master

</code></pre>

For your own system, you may need to adapt the repository URL and the branch selection accordingly.

If that sounds like meaningless gibberish to you - sorry! Please consult the documentation at http://www.z2-environment.eu/v21doc and go back to [[First_steps_with_z2]].

When you added that repository the following modules are available:

* org.springframework.orm

* org.springframework.security

* org.springframework.foundation   

* org.springframework.transaction

* org.springframework.jdbc         

* org.springframework.web

* com.zfabrik.springframework      

* com.zfabrik.springframework.web  

With the exception of those starting with "com.zfabrik", these do, more or less, correspond to the typical Spring modules found out there. 

Before you get frustrated by the amount of details in this Howto, please remember that there is practical samples available to help you check how things can really be assembled to work nicely:

* [[sample-spring-basic]]

* [[sample-jta-spring]]

h2. Using Spring in Web applications

This is the simplest and really just the standard case. If you do not strive for re-use across modules that use Spring, then there is not much to worry about. 

As usual, you define an application context in the WEB-INF folder of the Web application and set up a context listener in WEB-INF/web.xml to have the application 

context initialized as the Web app is started.

In order to have the minimal set of dependencies satisfied - i.e. not assuming you want to use the (very cool) AspectJ based Spring configuration, you should _add_ (i.e. augment whatever refs you already have) the following references to *java/z.properties*:

<pre><code class="python">

java.privateReferences=\

	com.zfabrik.springframework.web,\

	org.springframework.foundation,\

	org.springframework.web

</code></pre>

The reference to *com.zfabrik.springframework.web* is not strictly needed but adds the following capabilities:

* You implicitly get *com.zfabrik.springframework*, i.e. the integration features described below

* You can use a parent application context to your Web application application context as easily as you would hope (see below).

h2. Using Spring Context Support

The module *org.springframework.foundation* holds a Java component *org.springframework.foundation/context.support* that is not meant to be referenced but to be _included_.

Including a Java component means that it's resources (class files, jars,...) will be copied into the including scope rather than referenced via class loader delegation.

The difference is that in that case, all the includer sees is also be seen by the types in the included component. And that is exactly what context.support is about: It holds adapter classes that effectively have dangling dependencies on other prominent libraries. Say for example we are talking about the Lucene search engine library. If your Java component references the Lucene libs (which are not included with Z2 by default), and say you want to use the Spring adapter types, then include context.support by adding (i.e. customizing correspondingly) the private include:

<pre><code class="python">

java.privateIncludes=\

   org.springframework.foundation/context.support

</code></pre>

Typically it makes most sense to only use _private includes_. If you include into the API, which is possible, other modules that reference your API will find the included types

of your API with preference of their includes (as part of the parent-first delegation principle). So, they may not be able to repeat the same include pattern described above. 

h2. Spring stuff that requires includes

Several Spring use cases require the use of includes (more below). Among these are:

|_. Use case|_. What to private-include|_.Why|

|Spring context support|org.springframework.foundation/context.support|Dangling imports in spring lib|

|Spring AspectJ|org.springframework.foundation/aspects|Class loader bound application context (must be kept on scope - see below)|

|Spring Security|org.springframework.security/{config,ldap,...}|Dangling imports in spring lib|

h2. Using Spring in re-use modules

When going modular, you will leave the pure "Spring in a Web Application" path. That is, you may want to use Spring in modules that expose components and APIs to other modules. For example to implement shared services that are used in more than one Web Application, or for example to implement scheduled job execution.

*Define an Application Context in a Java Module*

In that case, you will not define an application context in a WEB-INF folder (as there most likely is none) but instead you will define a class path defined application context, or more specifically you will put your application context (most likely) in *java/src.impl/META-INF/applicationContext.xml* of your re-use module.

*Starting an Application Context*

Now that you have that application context, you need to make sure it is started. If you went this far, there is good reasons you use Z2 runtime dependencies to start it. Pre-requisite for that is to have the application context declared as a Z2 component. So you create a file *applicationContext.properties* in your module saying

<pre><code class="python">

com.zfabrik.component.type=org.springframework.context

#

# context config location is where the context is 

# actually defined. 

#

context.contextConfigLocation=classpath:META-INF/applicationContext.xml

</code></pre>

Once it is defined as a component, you can have it started via a "system state dependency":http://www.z2-environment.eu/v20doc#System%20States%20(core), via a "generic component depencency":http://www.z2-environment.eu/v20doc#CoreComponentProps.

Another way is to have it started implicitly from a bean component declaration. In that case, before providing the bean instance, the application context will be initialized.

*Exposing a bean from an application context*

Now that you have declared an application context component, you can actually expose beans from it as Z2 components that may be looked up from other modules. To do so, create a component like this:

<pre><code class="python">

com.zfabrik.component.type=org.springframework.bean

#

# the context that defines the bean (more than one

# bean can be exposed like this)

#

bean.context=<module name>/applicationContext

#

# the bean name

#

bean.name=<bean name>

</code></pre>

Now that a bean has been made available to other modules, the next natural question is how to actually refer to a Z2 component from a Spring application context.

*Importing a bean or just any component*

The module *com.zfabrik.springframework* contains a factory bean that just does that. Assuming you want to use component <module>/<name> which is of type (or has super type) my.Class, you would add to your importing application context:

<pre><code class="xml">

<bean id="beanId" class="com.zfabrik.springframework.ComponentFactoryBean">

  <property name="componentName" value="<module>/<name>" />

  <property name="className" value="my.Class" />

</bean>

</code></pre>

Ok, so far so good. Next subject is how to add more configuration magic to all of this.

h2. Using Spring's AspectJ configuration

By default, Spring's annotation support reaches as far as Spring "can see". That is, objects instantiated outside of Spring's control will not be subject to Spring configuration - simply because Spring had no chance to look at it. 

When using Spring's AspectJ feature, Spring's configuration reach can be extended to virtually anything within the implementation scope. Normally, configuring your build to include the AspectJ compilation can be tricky and tiring. The alternative of using load-time-weaving is rather error-prone as types may not have been loaded before the aspect has been registered - something where you can so easily fool yourself.

Fortunately for you, the Spring integration features of Z2 also provide a compiler extension for Spring with AspectJ. To use it, you need to modify your *java/z.properties* to reflect the following includes and refs and in particular the compiler settings:

<pre><code class="python">

java.privateReferences=\

	com.zfabrik.springframework,\

	org.springframework.foundation,\

	org.springframework.orm,\

	org.springframework.transaction

java.privateIncludes=\

	org.springframework.foundation/aspects

java.compile.order=java,spring_aspectj

</code></pre>

The refs to spring transaction and spring ORM look unintuitive. And they are. At the time of this writing the Spring aspect unfortunately still required those.

When you have applied the configuration above, you can make any type Spring configurable by annotating it with <code>@Configurable</code>. For example the "ControllerServlet":http://redmine.z2-environment.net/projects/z2-samples/repository/z2-samples-spring-basic/revisions/master/entry/com.zfabrik.samples.spring-basic.frontend/java/src.impl/com/zfabrik/samples/impl/frontend/ControllerServlet.java in the sample *z2-samples.spring-basic* has the following skeleton:

<pre><code class="java">

@Configurable

public class ControllerServlet extends HttpServlet {

        @Autowired

        private IComputationService computations;

        @Override

        protected void service(HttpServletRequest request, HttpServletResponse response) throws ServletException, IOException {

            //...

        }

}

</code></pre>

Now that all complexity of AspectJ compilation is completely out of the way, using Spring AspectJ can realize all its advantages over regular Spring AOP. Most notably, Spring AspectJ does not require proxy objects as Spring AOP does. This has a lot of simplifying implications. For example, annotations like @Transactional now work regardless of who is calling (inside or outside) and what methods are annotated. Similarly, other annotations such as those of Spring security work as naively expected. 

*Simply put: Spring AspectJ does it right where Spring AOP could not due to technical limitations.*

The whole subject is not completely trivial. For a deeper understanding we suggest to read:

* "Aspect Oriented Programming with Spring (Springsource)":http://docs.spring.io/spring/docs/2.5.x/reference/aop.html#aop-ataspectj

* "A starting point for pro and cons discussion (Stackoverflow)":http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1606559/spring-aop-vs-aspectj

* "Pitfalls of Spring proxying (external blog)":http://nurkiewicz.blogspot.de/2011/10/spring-pitfalls-proxying.html

h3. Making sure to configure for Spring AspectJ correctly

In order to avoid proxying when using Spring AspectJ, which you should to have one consistent approach, make sure that you apply a @mode="aspectj"@ attribute where possible.

This includes:

* the @<tx:annotation-driven/>@ annotation. Make sure it reads @<tx:annotation-driven mode="aspectj"/>@ (and possibly other attributes)

* the @<security:global-method-security/>@ annotation. Make sure it reads @<security:global-method-security mode="aspectj"/>@ (and possibly other attributes)

Use of the Spring aspects require to include the matching aspect libraries. In particular:

* When using Spring security aspects, add @org.springframework.security/aspects@ to your private includes

For example, an advanced Spring usage java component configuration may look like this:

<pre><code class="python">

com.zfabrik.component.type=com.zfabrik.java

java.privateReferences=\

    org.springframework.foundation,\

    org.springframework.orm,\

    org.springframework.web,\

    org.springframework.transaction,\

    org.springframework.security

java.privateIncludes=\

    org.springframework.security/config,\

    org.springframework.security/aspects,\

    org.springframework.security/taglibs,\

    org.springframework.security/web,\

    org.springframework.foundation/aspects,\

    org.springframework.foundation/context.support

#

# enables the processing of @Secured annotations in the implementation

#

aspectj.privateAspectPathByClass=\

	org.springframework.security.access.intercept.aspectj.aspect.AnnotationSecurityAspect

java.compile.order=java,spring_aspectj

</code></pre>

See also 

* "AspectJCompiler":http://www.z2-environment.net/javadoc/com.zfabrik.springframework!2Fjava/impl/com/zfabrik/impl/springframework/AspectJCompiler.html

* [[sample-spring-basic]] that also contains a Spring Security part.

h3. More important things to know about Spring with AspectJ

As always, there is some important pitfalls to watch out for. The Spring AspectJ integration roughly works as follows: 

# When an application context is loaded that has <context:spring-configured /> and the Spring aspect classes are on the classpath (i.e. can be found by the class loader of the application context), then the current application context will be set as a static class variable of one Spring aspect implementation class.

# Later, when a configurable object is being instantiated, the woven-in code will look for that static class variable to determine the application context to take configuration from.

This has a few dramatic consequences:

* If you would have two application contexts seeing the same static class variable they would override each other and hence you essentially lose control over what configuration is effective.

* Hence you should not using Spring AspectJ configuration in API types, as anyone referring to your API would not be able to repeat the trick.

That's why: *Only use Spring AspectJ in implementations, i.e. under src.impl or src.test*

h2. Using a parent application context in a Web application application context

Sometimes, later, when you find that your module has a web app but in addition you want to expose services, from the very same module, i.e. when you have spring configured objects in the web app but also a classpath defined application context that should serve as a _parent application context_ to the one of the web app (admittedly an advanced case), then you will find that that is slightly tricky to achieve (see e.g. http://blog.springsource.org/2007/06/11/using-a-shared-parent-application-context-in-a-multi-war-spring-application/). 

The class *com.zfabrik.springframework.web.ComponentParentContextContextLoaderListener* is a drop-in replacement for Spring's ContextLoaderListener implementation that simplifies that use-case as explained in the "javadoc":http://www.z2-environment.net/javadoc/com.zfabrik.springframework.web!2Fjava/api/com/zfabrik/springframework/web/ComponentParentContextContextLoaderListener.html.

h2. Advanced notes

As may have leaked through above already, some features of the Spring framework have slightly non-trivial prerequisites. In general these require that Spring provided libraries are used within the context of other Java components - as for context.support above - and that requires some explanation:

At runtime, Java components in Z2 have two class loader instances. One for the API definitions of the component, the other for the implementation definitions of the component. The latter is not visible to any referencing component, while the former is. Visibility is achieved by class loader delegation. That is, the class loaders of a referencing Java component will first delegate to the API class loader of the referenced component when looking for a type before checking their own resources. 

The delegation sequence is always strictly along the references. 

When we use the term shared library or shared Java component, we are referring to a Java component that can be referenced by others to provide some functionality. At runtime, the types of that Java component are loaded exactly once into the VM's memory. As a side-effect, static class members for example will be shared amongst all usages.

The alternative to sharing a Java component is to “include” a Java component. When a Java component references a component of type *com.zfabrik.files* or *com.zfabrik.java*, libraries and class files of the referenced component will be copied into the referencing component (depending on the reference either into the API or the implementation part). In that case, the types provided by the files component are used in the context of there referencing component and may be loaded several times.

Considering Spring there are two cases that mandate a non-shared use of libraries.

h3. Dangling Imports

Some Spring libraries provide integration of Spring with a variety of third-party libraries. When those libraries were compiled, all those third-party libraries were present on the compilation class path. Java's late linking paradigm allows to use those libraries without the presence of the third-party libraries as long as visibility of those types is not necessary yet.

One example of such a library is the context support Spring module. See above for more details.

h3. Static Members Holding Singletons

Another reason that mandates in context use is module specific static initialization. In other words there is a class that holds static, class-level data that is specific to the using context.

One example of such is the Spring AspectJ context that points to its underlying application context by a class variable. As a consequence, sharing these classes between modules with different application context would lead to confusions about what application context is used during the application of the Spring aspect. That is why the Spring AspectJ library should always be included by a private reference, and the implementation should use only one application context as far as AspectJ configuration is concerned.